• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Higher Thought Cannabis Game

  • Home
  • The Aim of Higher Thought
    • The Story of Our Game
    • Our Friendly Game
    • Q&A
    • Instructions for Play
  • Try the Game for Free!
  • What Players Say
  • Memes
  • Blog
  • Press
  • Contact
  • BUY THE GAME
    • Purchase now
    • Find the Game Near You
You are here: Home / Recent Thoughts / Gaslit by Heroes

January 14, 2022 By Marc Polonsky 4 Comments

Gaslit by Heroes

Gaslit by Heroes

In 2015, the film This Changes Everything was premiering at the Hollywood Theatre in Portland, OR (where I live). The film, by Avi Lewis, is kind of a companion piece to the book of the same title by Naomi Klein, Lewis’s wife. Both the book and the film are about climate change.

The night I went, Lewis and Klein were there in person to take questions when the movie ended. Most questions, including my own, were addressed to Ms. Klein. I alluded to an assertion from her brilliant book that we would have to, collectively, cut back to 1970s levels of consumption in order to set ourselves on a sustainable path and avoid the worst consequences of global warming. My question was – for practical purposes, what would that entail? With billions more people in the world now than 40 years ago, how would our lifestyles have to change in order to return to collective energy consumption levels of the ‘70s?

I was stunned by the response I received from Klein.

“Well, we’re not going back to bell bottoms and disco,” she chuckled. 

Mr. Lewis chimed in similarly. In jovial tag team fashion, they ridiculed my question with smirking references to elements of 1970s American culture. 

I was sure they had misunderstood me. But the more I tried to clarify – i.e. what might cutting back our collectively energy consumption to sustainable levels actually LOOK LIKE in our day-to-day lives? – the more they blew me off with snarky, sarcastic replies.

It was only much later that I realized they had not misunderstood me at all. They had simply chosen not to answer me seriously. 

In the moment, the possibility that these two climate heroes were behaving disingenuously had never occurred to me.

I still don’t entirely understand it.

After the event, I wrote a detailed letter to Naomi Klein, repeating my question in the clearest possible terms and assuring her I was not asking about music or clothing fashions. Sometime later, I received a terse response from her secretary stating that Ms. Klein was much too busy with her writing and speaking and traveling schedule to address my questions.

Wow.

In retrospect, I recall one or two other telling moments from that night. 

Portland is a very creative city. One attendee to the event had devised an elaborate, semi-motorized bicycle-type vehicle with considerable storage space (almost as much as a car), and he had ridden to the show on that contraption – as a demonstration of the types of energy savings that are possible if we think out of the box. I recall that Mr. Lewis made a wryly amused and dismissive reference to this vehicle as if it were nothing more than emblematic of Portland’s famous “weirdness.”

I also recall that one or the other of them made a surprisingly condescending remark with respect to 350PDX, our local climate change activist group.  

But most of all, I remember a conversation I had with another audience member at the end of the evening, to whom I expressed my frustration at how my question had been misinterpreted and rebuffed.

She told me, “I think they [Klein and Lewis] want to avoid focusing on personal choices in general, because that’s a mistake. Our personal lifestyle choices aren’t going to make anything remotely close to the needed difference. It’s about the big players, the fossil fuel industry. We need to train our focus on them, not on ourselves. Thinking we personally have the responsibility is actually just a distraction from the real issue.”

Hm. Really?

Of course I have no idea what Naomi Klein and her husband really believe about personal choices, but here’s what I think: If you’re alive, you have a part to play. 

We are not mere spectators of our unfolding world. We are participants in history. 

Saying that personal choices don’t matter is like telling people not to vote. “Hey, come on. Let’s go fishing instead. You really think your ONE VOTE is going to matter?” 

Yes. Collectively, our individual choices do matter – a lot. And in that sense, our consumption choices are a lot like voting. 

For humanity to somehow avert the worst consequences of climate change (food shortages, clean water shortages, wars for resources, ocean acidification, catastrophic sea level rises, coral reef decimation …) it will take some currently unimaginable combination of:

  • Radical conservation
  • “Green” technology and planning
  • A profound shift in our collective consciousness and value structure

I’ll have a lot more to say about all this in weeks to come.

darkness

Share this:

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)

Filed Under: Recent Thoughts

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. David Opo says

    January 14, 2022 at 10:23 pm

    I loved this blog post. It said more in a page text then I have read in 10,000 word essays. Thanks

    Reply
    • Marc Polonsky says

      January 15, 2022 at 5:58 am

      David, thank you so much for this comment. It means a lot to me. And thanks for reading!

      Marc

      Reply

Trackbacks

  1. Hearing Greta - Higher Thought Cannabis Game says:
    January 28, 2022 at 3:29 pm

    […] ENDING THE CLIMATE CRISIS IN ONE GENERATION by Paul Hawken or THIS CHANGES EVERYTHING by Naomi Klein, in and of itself, absent any other action, all this really amounts to is another form of […]

    Reply
  2. In Praise of Imperfect Offerings - Higher Thought Cannabis Game says:
    February 11, 2022 at 2:51 pm

    […] As I stated a couple of newsletters ago, I think there are three essential dimensions to tackling climate change: […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Most Popular Recent Thoughts

Recent Thoughts

  • Darkness. My old friend?
    A Totally Creepy Thought that I Love for Some Reason
  • Playing Higher Thought the Cannabis Game with ChatGPT
    Why ChatGPT Can’t Play Higher Thought
  • ego reactivity
    Moments of Ego Reactivity
  • adventures of the heart
    The Heart Doesn’t Judge; It Just Says “Ouch!”
  • Pretend it's your dream
    Pretend It’s Your Dream
  • Art I don't like
    Art I Don’t Like
  • Burrito epiphany
    Epiphany at the Burrito Shop
  • Infinite Freedom
    Infinite Freedom
  • Miami Dolphins
    Goodbye to an Old Friend?
  • An understated new year
    An Understated New Year’s Moment
  • Fun is sacred - Higher Thought Cannabis Game
    Aphorisms from My Inner Guru
  • Infinite Time
    Infinite Time
  • The goddess laughs - Higher Thought Game
    People Make Plans and the Goddess Laughs
  • Citizenship
    Citizenship!
  • Things we learn in life
    What We’re Here to Learn
  • The Homeless Guy who wouldn't take no for an answer
    The Homeless Guy Who Wouldn’t Take No for an Answer
  • Nalu Kava: A Haven for Thoughtful People
  • hungry child
    They Were There But Now They’re Gone
  • Portland Adult Soapbox Derby, Tabor Park
    No Regrets
  • What is the internet doing to our brains
    Let’s Take This Conversation to the Real World!

Footer

Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • YouTube

Contact Higher Thought

Email Higher Thought

Telephone: (503) 345-5533

Privacy Policy

Copyright 2018–2021 Higher Thought Games™ LLC. All rights reserved.

Copyright © 2023 · Altitude Pro On Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

Higher Thought: The Cannabis Game

Get Higher Thought updates, tips, news, meet-ups and bargains!

Share higher thoughts, play the game live, get special discounts, and more!

Sign Me Up for the Kick-Ass Friday Newsflash!

Never see this message again.